STONES SOUND STUDIO
DC TESTING WOOFERS DOME TWEETER & RIBBON SPEAKERS
by Russell Storey 2005
DOME and RIBBON TWEETERS (description) Large & Small diaphragms. more ...........>> PHASE_IT Speaker Phase tester available from Stones Sound Studio +
Ribbon Tweeter True ribbons (or Super Tweeters with a
transformer) Have an
impedance coupling transformer to couple the very low impedance of the ribbon
diaphragm to the crossover circuit network .The crossover circuit sees an almost
constant ac impedance of nominally 4 or 8 ohms from 2 to 40Khz (120Khz TAD
Pioneer) with high
quality coupling transformer design making them excellent constant loads with
linear impedance and group delay.
The True Ribbon tweeters dc
phase (polarity) can be tested by applying a low voltage dc to the primary side of
the transformer by switching this dc voltage from a battery on and off to the
ribbons terminals like a light switch to see the ribbon diaphragm move. The
primary resistance of a ribbon transformer is usually only 0.1 ohms DC which can
be difficult to read with normal digital voltmeters. Ribbon diaphragms can be
damage very easily with low order 6db crossovers and also by using too low a
crossover frequency usually >4kHz is a reasonable starting point for any type of
12 18 24 db crossover.
Ribbon diaphragm material has traditionally been made from wafer thin
Aluminium or Aluminium alloys with various types of corrugations stamped into
the material to add strength ,rigidity and dampen any unwanted resonances in the
response . Now composite Alloy diaphragms are available which achieve greater
damping of unwanted harmonic resonances and increased power handling of the
diaphragm by using larger BL magnetic fields supplied by Neo Magnets.
Ribbon diaphragm lengths can vary from 40 to 160mm The larger 160mm ribbons can
go to lower crossover cut off frequency's usually>900Hz is a reasonable starting
point for any type of 12 18 24 db crossover given the higher power rating
of a larger ribbon.
The larger Ribbon Tweeters of (120 to 160mm in length) are suitable for low or
high power 2 way speaker crossover designs for high end high definition studio
monitors PA Home theatre and music speaker systems
Because the ribbon diaphragms mass is only 8 to 25 mgs (milligrams) for Small
ribbons or 35 to 80mgs for Large ribbons then wind generated from an over head fan or open exterior door way can bend and
damage the diaphragm .I recommend some form of cover over the front of the
ribbon tweeter when not in use . The detail from these tweeters can be excellent to 3
dimensional holographic with the good application and crossover design
.Ribbon tweeters are usually
more expensive than Planar Magnetic (leaf tweeters) but are usually
worth the exercise.
Leaf Tweeter Planar Magnetic (i.e. not a
"true" ribbon has no transformer ) .The diaphragm is usually made from
an alloy
foil laminated onto Kapton base which is etched using printed circuit board
techniques to create a rectangular or circular voice coil. This laminated diaphragm sits
over the top of high flux density(BL)) bar magnets which generated a very
strong magnetic field behind and in front of the diaphragm. The Planar
Magnetic leaf tweeter is more robust than the true ribbon tweeter but suffers from
a higher diaphgram mass and ultimately less transit response and low level detail .Planar magnetic technology has improved with smaller neo magnets
and diaphgram base materials like mylar,kapton giving it a more stable and
flexible diaphgram under higher power
levels than the true Ribbon tweeter. The detail from these tweeters can be excellent and are
lese expensive to purchase than the true ribbon tweeter.
Dome Tweeter Dome tweeters are usually made from 3 common materials pvc ,metal or fabric (poly ,silk,berillium,titanium) and have very small dome movements (excurtions)with an Xmax of (+/- 0.75 to 1.5mm).Diaphram mass depends on type of material used and with special fabrics like doped and treated the mass of the moving diaphragm is usually in the range from (0.22 to 1.5)gms .Because of their small surface area and stiff compliance they require a slightly higher dc voltage to move the tweeter diaphragm so you can it actually can be seen moving. A voltage of 3v is usually sufficient to see the dome move but some types of tweeters will require 4 to 6 v to see any movement. The voltage should be only applied momentariarily for a fraction of a second or else the voice coil or dome assembly will be damaged.Some manufactures actually reverse the phase of the diaphragm in accordance with normal studio microphone phasing be careful. This is why some 2 channel Cd recordings sound flat due to a reverse phasing some where in the recording studio chain like the microphone , internal studio cabling ,or the sound mixing console .This principal also applies to DVD movie and music sound tracks. Reversing the speaker leads to both left and right speakers will change the top end detail and sound stage radically this is why you have to know is it my tweeter or bass driver that is reverse phased or is it a recording phase error. Some amplifiers have a reverse speaker switch which will do the same as reversing the connections to the speakers.
TESTING PROCEDURE FOR TRUE RIBBON TWEETERS using a DC battery source
Ribbon Tweeter true (with transformer) DC Polatity test.
#You can check the polarity of the true ribbon tweeter by placing a (1.5V battery ) with a 68 ohm 1watt ( protection resistor) in series with the ribbon tweeter ( +Ve ) terminal.
ü
CORRECT IN PHASE :
If the phasing of the terminals is
correct the ribbon diaphgram should move outwards
around (1mm )or so
when the #battery is applied. This should be the red terminal
ü WRONG OUT OF PHASE :If the terminals are the wrong way round then the ribbon diaphragm will move inwards when the battery is applied.
ü Do not apply the battery for more than a few seconds at a time .
ü If you put a battery across the ribbon tweeter with out the ( protection resistor) the ribbon diaphgram will be damage
SEE _ Bass speaker battery phase test (DC Only) (diagram below) the same principal applies to the ribbon tweeter diaphram direction of movement. Note only use a 1.5V battery for ribbon tweete
Ribbon Tweeter true (with transformer) AC Pulse Acoustic Phase and Polarity test.
NOTE : A 9V 25Hz single shot positive edge pulse must be applied to the ribbon tweeter via 4.7 uF capacitor (6db HP filter) in series with the +(VE ) terminal and correct acoustic phase is monitored by a Microphone the diaphragm should move upwards if the polarity is correct. ( more .. see PHASE_IT Speaker Phase tester available from Stones Sound Studio +
SUB WOOFERS BASS/MID MIDRANGE and WIDE-RANGE speakers ( more ...........>> PHASE_IT Speaker Phase tester available from Stones Sound Studio
SUB WOOFERS Can have very low dc voice coil resistance so
usually we need to use a 2x 1.5V batteries (3V) to get enough current
to more the voice coil especially with car sound drivers with twin 2 ohm
voice coils
Single Voice coils use a 2x 1.5V batteries (3V) see (BASS SPEAKER BATTERY PHASE TEST (dc) ONLY)diagram below
Double Voice coils Test the phase of the voice coils one at a time to check if the ternminals are marked correctly.Then join the two subwoofer voice coils together in series (like connecting 2 batterys to get 3volts)and the cone should move in and out according to the diagram below
BASS/MID
Single Voice coils use a 2x 1.5V batteries (3V) see (BASS SPEAKER BATTERY PHASE TEST (dc) ONLY)diagram below
Double Voice coils Test the phase of the voice coils one at a time to check if the ternminals are marked correctly.Then join the two bass/mid voice coils together in series (like connecting 2 batterys to get 3volts)and the cone should move in and out according to the diagram below
MIDRANGE
Single Voice coils use a 2x 1.5V batteries (3V) see (BASS SPEAKER BATTERY PHASE TEST (dc) ONLY)diagram below
WIDERANGE
Single Voice coils use a 2x 1.5V batteries (3V) see (BASS SPEAKER BATTERY PHASE TEST (dc) ONLY)diagram below
HORN COMPRESSION DRIVERS Horn compression PA drivers are usually some form of alloy with their domes similar to a tweeter diaphram but an inverted (concave) diaphram with voice diameters from 35 to 65mm in diameter and are designed to handle higher average power than conventential dome tweeters because of there application . Materials link aluminimum,berrilium,and tiatanium are used because of the heat sink effect the metal diaphram provides for the voice coil and also provide good power bandwidth inconjuction with alloy coil formers for commercial Pa and sound reinforcement applications . The diaphram is mounted at the rear of the Horn Flare .The Horn Compression unit (itself) can be removed manually from the horn flare by unscrewing it or by removing 4 mounting screws.
Single Voice coils use a 2x 1.5V batteries (3V) see (BASS SPEAKER BATTERY PHASE TEST (dc) ONLY) diagram below
BASS SPEAKER BATTERY PHASE TEST (dc) ONLY) Diagram
TESTING THE
CROSSOVERS IN THE
(Peerless speaker Kit Boxes)
CROSSOVER UNIT IMPEDANCE (dc) test only
Attach a DVM ( Digital volt meter) on the low
ohms range across the rear of the twin terminal cup +VE & -VE terminals and
measure the dc resistance see table below .(Approximate measured values) for
speaker Kits
MODEL |
DVM METER READING (approximate) |
R150 |
5.1 to 6.2 ohms |
R255 R255C |
3.1 to 3.6 ohms |
R455 R450 |
3.1 to 3.6 ohms |
Russell Storey
Stones Sound Studio (Aust )